I picked the Rumble.
Despite royally fucking up the Wrestlemania that followed, Royal Rumble was one of the most crazy entertaining shows I've ever watched live, if not *the* most entertaining show I've watched live. I literally did not leave my seat once, and while there was some pretty useless filler on the show (i.e. APA vs Outlaws), it was kept short and the title match, as well as the Rumble event, were A-Grade material all the way.
Cactus/Hunter remains today one of the most insane fucking brawls I've seen, and Big Show had me convinced that he was going to actually defy logic and win the damn Rumble, despite Rocky being the obvious pick.
Great stuff.
UYI